Wilson Counters Critics of U.S.-India Nuclear Proposal

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
CONTACT: Emily Lawrimore
202-225-2452 (W)
202-468-3258 (C)

May 25, 2006

Wilson Counters Critics of U.S.-India Nuclear Proposal

Today, Congressman Joe Wilson (R- SC) joined Congressmen Dan Burton (R- IN), Gary Ackerman (D-NY), and Joe Crowley (D-NY) in co-authoring a Dear Colleague letter responding to critics of the proposed civilian nuclear agreement between the United States and India. Congressman Wilson made the following statement about the letter:

“Throughout the past few months, critics of the civilian nuclear proposal have made several erroneous statements which completely misrepresent the intent of this potential partnership. Our letter counters these false claims and reaffirms our support for this visionary agreement.”

Countering the Critics:

1. Critics claim the proposed agreement poses potential negative impacts on nonproliferation.

“On the contrary, the agreement greatly strengthens the international nonproliferation system. India has long been largely outside of international nonproliferation regimes. Under this agreement, India will place 14 of 22 existing and planned nuclear facilities under IAEA safeguards. Further, once a reactor has been placed under safeguards, it will be that way permanently and without conditions”

2. Critics claim the proposed agreement treats India’s civilian nuclear program differently than those of other countries.

“However, the fact that the agreement provides unique treatment for India is based on the recognition of the very different factual situation regarding India compared to other countries with a history of proliferation problems. For 30 years, India has protected its nuclear programs. It has not engaged in or allowed proliferation of its nuclear technology. Simply put, India is treated uniquely because of its history of maintaining a successful nuclear nonproliferation regime.”

*Please click on the attached document to view the entire letter.

###